Insight as entropy production

In his Math 2.0 slides, Terence Tao calls open problems in pure mathematics “lighthouses.” They guide mathematicians through the surrounding landscape. The attempts to reach them, including failures and partial successes, can generate more understanding than a final proof alone. If an automated tool supplies the proof too early, some of those paths may never be explored. (Slide 16.)

Tao also proposes a new experimental mathematics in which large data sets permit population surveys of problems rather than isolated case studies. (Slide 13.) Taken together, these suggestions invite us to take pleasure in discovering the contours of a landscape besides finding its destination valleys. This made me wonder whether a similar question could change how we study consciousness.

We often speak of an awareness state as a place to get to. I might want to feel less afraid, more open, or less trapped in recurring worrisome thoughts that are making me see the world in a narrow way. A psychedelic experience may give me access to a relatively more open state that had previously seemed impossible. A skillful way of learning to live life might eventually take me there too. Yet if two routes lead to something I describe with the same word—“openness,” let's say—have they made me the same person in the sense that matters?

Perhaps not. After one route, I may know vividly that openness is possible, while being unable to find a path to it in ordinary circumstances. After another, I may know how openness emerged from choosing to stay with fear in spite of fear, what changed at each step, and which small movement I could make. The sudden experience may be immensely valuable and reorganize my expectations so deeply that paths open up afterward, yet the endpoint description alone may not tell us what needed to change.

Here is the stronger claim I want to explore: a theory of consciousness may need to treat possible trajectories, and not only its momentary states, as fundamental objects. The experience at time t might depend on where a person came from; where they can go next might depend on insights they received from how they arrived. The first-person experience of living life could be an available set of allowed dance movements in a certain neighborhood of an awareness landscape. So, a map of conscious states that ignores contours and dynamics leaves out part of the phenomenon it is trying to explain.

This is where thermodynamics becomes more than a metaphor. In stochastic thermodynamics, one can study a system through distributions of trajectories, including how likely a sequence is compared with an appropriately defined reversed sequence. This gives a precise way to investigate irreversibility. I am asking whether a comparable trajectory-level theory could be constructed for conscious experience: one with defined states, transitions, constraints, and quantities that change when a path is traversed.

Such a theory would need to answer difficult questions. What counts as the same experiential state across two people, or even across two moments in one person? Which aspects of history stay relevant in predicting possible futures? Could a measure of directional asymmetry in reported experience and neural dynamics distinguish a route that reliably changes future accessibility from one that produces a temporary excursion? And how would we know that this measure tracks understanding, rather than simply creating memory?

One attractive hypothesis could be that insight is entropy production in this new thermodynamics. If it is a temporary state induced by a psychedelic substance, a person could simply return to a familiar state in a reversible way without any change in who they are. Having learned something about the fears through the lived experience of small movements, one may still feel fear the next day, but some movement that was formerly unavailable may now be possible, and a route back to openness may become easier to find. The insight thus might consist of the consequences that are left with a person and make them who they are, in possible journeys.

Tao’s lighthouse metaphor precisely reminded me that arriving magically at a dream island for a day does not make us wise voyagers. On the other hand, his proposal for population surveys made me think that perhaps a mature theory of consciousness would tell us not only which states exist, but which trajectories are statistically possible in human experience, under what conditions, and what traces those transitions leave behind. That is the landscape I want to understand.

Copyright © 2026 • Ani • Licensed under CC-BY-NC-NA